Father Alan Nagle was ordained on May 20, 1967. In 2009, a survivor reported that Nagle sexually abused him as a freshman at Calvert Hall High School during an overnight retreat to Clare O’Dwyer Retreat House in Sparks, MD, in 1970. The abuse consisted primarily of fondling. In 2018, a second survivor reported that Nagle “became aggressive and laid in bed with him naked.” Nagle was reported to have issues with alcoholism. He died on July 6, 1997.
| Date | Church/Organization | Location |
| 1966-1967 | All Saints Church | Baltimore, MD |
| 1967-1973 | Church of the Immaculate Conception | Towson, MD |
| 1973-1978 | St. Margaret’s Church | Bel Air, MD |
| 1978-1980 | St. Anne’s Melkite-Greek Catholic Church | North Hollywood, CA |
